Frequently Asked Questions
Understanding commercial property tax assessments can be complex, particularly across multiple jurisdictions. The questions below address common issues we see across markets and property types.
Because rules and procedures vary by state, these answers are general in nature. For guidance specific to your property or jurisdiction, we recommend speaking directly with an APTC representative.
Understanding Property Tax Assessments
-
Most jurisdictions determine value using a combination of income, sales comparison, and cost-based approaches. These models rely on market assumptions that don’t always reflect the specific performance or condition of your property, which is why assessments often warrant review.
-
Assessors typically use mass-appraisal systems that apply standardized assumptions across many properties. These systems may not account for factors like vacancy, deferred maintenance, or local market conditions, leading to discrepancies.
-
A purchase price may affect an assessment, but it is not always determinative. Some jurisdictions rely heavily on sales data, while others weigh sales alongside other valuation methods.
In many jurisdictions, taxpayers have successfully shown that assessed value should be based instead on current market rents, expenses, occupancy, and market-based credit assumptions—rather than the terms of a specific in-place tenant.
-
Increases often result from updated market data, reassessment cycles, or changes in valuation models. These updates may not fully reflect current property performance or localized conditions.
When and Why to Appeal
-
Common indicators include significant increases in assessed value, a disconnect between assessed value and income performance, or market conditions that are not reflected in the assessment.
In some jurisdictions, another red flag is when the subject property’s assessment is materially higher than the assessments of comparable properties.
-
Appeals are typically filed after assessment notices are issued and must be submitted within strict deadlines. Reviewing your assessment early is critical to preserving your options.
-
For commercial properties, even modest valuation adjustments can result in meaningful tax savings. A review can help determine whether an appeal is justified.
The Appeal Process
-
The process generally includes filing a formal challenge, presenting supporting evidence, and participating in a review or hearing. Additional levels of appeal may be available depending on the jurisdiction.
-
Appeal timelines vary by jurisdiction and by the complexity of the case. Some matters resolve in a matter of months, while others can take several years.
-
Many jurisdictions allow for further review through administrative boards or courts. The available options depend on local rules.
-
Evidence often includes income and expense data, comparable sales, appraisals, and documentation of property condition or operational challenges.
-
Not always. Many assessments rely on standardized assumptions that may not reflect a property’s actual performance. A thorough review should compare the assessment to current market data and adjust for the property’s specific circumstances.
-
Appraisals can be useful, but they are not always required. The most effective evidence depends on the property type and jurisdiction.
For complex commercial properties, however, a well-supported appraisal is often critical—not only to support the value conclusion, but also to provide credible expert testimony. Selecting an appraiser who can work effectively with counsel is important and is best coordinated through your attorney.
Valuation & Evidence
-
Each state—and often each county—has its own rules, deadlines, and valuation methods. Managing multiple properties requires coordination across jurisdictions.
-
Yes. A coordinated approach helps ensure consistency, track deadlines, and identify opportunities across multiple properties.
Multi-State & Portfolio Considerations
Working with APTC
-
APTC is a national alliance of law firms focused exclusively on commercial and industrial property tax matters.
-
No. APTC works exclusively with commercial and industrial property owners and organizations.
-
The first step is connecting with the APTC representative in your state. They can review your property and advise on next steps.
Still have questions?
Connect with an APTC representative to discuss your property or portfolio, or search for a member firm in your state.